If you own a small business in your local community, such as a landscaping company, dental practice or family bakery, you may have been advised to "become an S corp" to save on taxes. However, most people who recommend this can't explain what it actually means. It is the difference between the pitch and the paperwork that causes business owners to get into trouble.
Here's some scale to start with. For tax year 2023, the IRS counted 5,440,879 active Form 1120-S returns, which reported $814.531 billion in pretax net income minus deficit (IRS, 2023). That's a lot of businesses relying on the same tax structure. Catholic business owners are part of this group, though no data isolates their share — the Pew Research Center estimated that there were approximately 53 million Catholic adults in the United States in 2024, spread across all regions, with 29% in the South and 26% in the Northeast (Pew Research Center, 2025).
An S corporation can offer genuine tax benefits. However, it also comes with payroll rules and a separate tax return, not to mention penalties that can mount up quickly if you miss a deadline. This article explains how the structure works, who it helps and where the pitfalls lie, so you can have an informed conversation with an accountant instead of passively accepting a sales pitch.
Key takeaways
- An S corporation is a pass-through entity, meaning that profits are generally taxed on the owners' tax returns rather than at the company level.
- For tax years 2024 and 2025, the self-employment tax rate was 15.3% — 12.4% for Social Security and 2.9% for Medicare (IRS, 2025).
- Owners who work in the business are expected to pay themselves 'reasonable compensation' as a salary, and courts have reclassified distributions as wages when they didn't.
- Late filing of Form 1120-S carried a penalty of $245 per shareholder per month for the 2024 tax year and $255 for the 2025 tax year (IRS, 2025).
- As state rules vary widely, you should check with your own state's revenue department.
Table of Contents
Do S Corps pay taxes at all?
This is the question that confuses almost everyone. So, let's answer it directly: an S corporation usually doesn't pay federal income tax itself. In tax terms, it's what's known as a 'pass-through' entity. This means that the profit 'passes through' to the owners, who report their share on their personal tax returns and pay tax on it there.
So, does an S corp pay taxes? At the federal level, mostly no — the income is generally taxed once, on the shareholders' personal returns. That's different from a regular C corporation, where the company pays corporate income tax and owners get taxed again on dividends.
However, 'no federal income tax at the company level' does not mean 'no filing'. Businesses still file a corporate tax return — Form 1120-S — every year and provide each owner with a Schedule K-1 showing their share of the pass-through income. Several states also charge the entity directly. California, for example, imposed a general 1.5% S corporation tax for the 2025 tax year, plus an $800 minimum franchise tax. This minimum was waived for a newly formed corporation's first taxable year (California Franchise Tax Board, 2026). New York uses an entirely different system, with minimum fixed-dollar taxes on its Form CT-3-S ranging from $25 for receipts up to $100,000, to $4,500 for receipts over $25 million for the 2025 tax year (New York State Department of Taxation and Finance, 2025).
In summary, the federal and state stories are two separate things. Check with your own state's revenue department before assuming that your business owes nothing.
Where do the savings actually come from?
The main advantage of an S corporation is the savings on self-employment tax. Here's how it works.
If you run a business as a sole proprietor, your profits are subject to self-employment tax. For tax years 2024 and 2025, this was set at 15.3% — 12.4% for Social Security and 2.9% for Medicare (IRS, 2025). The Social Security portion applied up to a wage base of $168,600 for the 2024 tax year and $176,100 for the 2025 tax year, while the Medicare portion had no cap (IRS, 2025). Higher earners also faced an additional 0.9% Medicare tax on combined earnings above $200,000 for single filers and $250,000 for married couples filing jointly in the same years (IRS, 2025).
The math changes with an S corporation. You split your earnings into two categories: a salary, which is paid to you as an employee and is subject to payroll taxes, and a distribution of the remaining profit, which is generally not subject to Social Security and Medicare tax. That second bucket is where the savings come from.
Suppose your bakery earns $120,000 in profit after expenses. As a sole proprietor, the full amount is used to calculate your self-employment tax. However, if you were to set up as an S corporation, you could pay yourself a reasonable salary and take the rest as a distribution, which is generally not subject to payroll taxes — a split a CPA should confirm for your situation. In one sentence, that's the main tax benefit of an S corp.
One thing to bear in mind is that a 2024 survey of 1,021 self-employed small-business owners in the U.S. found that 18% identified optimizing their tax strategy as a financial literacy challenge. However, that survey was not specific to Catholics or S corporations (Xero, 2024). If this feels slippery, you're not alone.
Do you need a Catholic accountant? Heritage Web can put you in touch.
The salary rule that trips people up
Here's where owners get into real trouble. You can't just pay yourself $1 in salary and take everything else as a tax-free distribution. The IRS expects an owner who works in the business to take reasonable compensation — broadly, a salary that reflects the value of the work you actually do, as the court cases below illustrate.
Courts have repeatedly backed the IRS on this. For example, in David E. Watson, P.C. v. United States, the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that $91,044 should be considered reasonable annual compensation for the 2002 and 2003 tax years, rather than the $24,000 salary that the owner had reported (U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, 2012). Similarly, in Sean McAlary Ltd., Inc. v. Commissioner, the Tax Court ruled that $83,200 was a reasonable salary for the 2006 tax year for an owner who had taken company funds but reported no wages — and that this sum was reclassified as wages for employment tax purposes (U.S. Tax Court, 2013).
The pattern is clear. If you pay yourself too little, the IRS can reclassify your distributions as wages, and you would then owe the payroll taxes on them — as happened in the cases above.
This isn't a fringe concern, either. A 2021 report by the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration (TIGTA) estimated that nearly $25 billion in officer compensation was potentially left off 266,095 unexamined single-shareholder S corporation returns from 2016 to 2018 — figures that were estimates, not amounts actually assessed. The underlying message is clear: the salary figure is important, and a competent S Corp CPA will assist you in documenting how you arrived at it.
Two Things Owners Forget: Basis and the QBI Deduction
Once you're an S corporation owner, two concepts come up constantly, and both deserve a little attention.
The first is the shareholder basis, which is essentially your investment in the company for tax purposes. It increases when the business makes a profit or you invest more money, and decreases when you receive distributions or the business makes a loss. Basis is important because it affects how much loss you can deduct and how your distributions are taxed. Starting with the 2021 tax year, Form 7203 replaced the old basis worksheet as a required attachment in certain situations, according to IRS guidance from 2022 — confirm the current form with your CPA. Its instructions list four triggers: claiming an S corporation loss, taking a non-dividend distribution, selling your stock or getting repaid on a shareholder loan (IRS, 2022).
The second is the qualified business income deduction under IRC § 199A, which can let eligible owners deduct a portion of their pass-through income. For tax year 2025, the wage-and-property and specified-service limitations began phasing in at taxable income of $394,600 for joint filers and $197,300 for other filers, with the ranges ending at $494,600 and $247,300 (IRS, 2025). The deduction was temporary for years, but Public Law 119-21, signed July 4, 2025, made § 199A permanent, with its amendments first affecting tax year 2026 for calendar-year taxpayers (U.S. Congress, 2025).
It's easy to get both of these wrong on your own. They're a big reason why many business owners hire help. A 2024 survey of 500 Latino small business owners found that 53% had paid for external financial or accounting support. However, that survey wasn't limited to Catholic or S corporation owners (Verizon Business, 2024).
The Paperwork — and the Penalties for Missing It
The process of becoming an S corporation begins with an IRS election. You file Form 2553 to apply for S status, which must be done within a set timeframe. If you miss this deadline, there may still be options available to you. According to Revenue Procedure 2013-30, simplified late-election relief is generally allowed if the business intended to have S status, the late election was the only issue, there is reasonable cause, the error was corrected diligently, shareholders provide the required consistency statements and the request is made within three years and 75 days of the intended effective date — though this guidance dates from 2013, so confirm it still applies (IRS, 2013).
Once you become an S corporation, the filing requirements become stricter. For tax year 2024 returns due in 2025, the late-filing penalty for Form 1120-S was $245 per shareholder per month, or part of a month, rising to $255 for tax year 2025 returns due in 2026 (IRC § 6699, IRS, 2025). A three-owner business that files four months late could face 3 × 4 × $255 = $3,060 for a 2025 return, and the penalty can run for up to 12 months.
Delinquency penalties on S corporation returns more broadly are not rare in the aggregate, though the IRS figures do not separately identify § 6699 late-filing assessments. In fiscal year 2025 the IRS assessed 540,452 S corporation income-tax delinquency penalties totaling about $1.0417 billion, across multiple tax years (IRS, 2025).
What about audit risk? It's low. IRS examination coverage of tax year 2023 S corporation returns was under 0.05% as of September 30, 2025, with 143 examinations closed and 915 in process — though coverage can rise as more returns get selected (IRS, 2025). Low odds, but the salary cases above show what happens when a return is picked. Don't let a small audit percentage talk you into cutting corners on reasonable compensation.
Is the S Corp right for your business?
The honest answer is that it depends, and anyone who tells you otherwise is trying to sell you something. S corporation status tends to pay off when a business earns enough profit that the savings from the self-employment tax outweigh the added costs of payroll processing, filing a separate return, paying state-level taxes, and paying an accountant's fee.
For a business that is just breaking even, the overhead can offset the benefits. For a profitable professional practice, however, the savings can be substantial. The breakeven point varies depending on your profit, state and family's overall tax situation, which is why there is no universal rule.
Here are a few questions to consider before making a decision:
- Is the business consistently generating a profit that exceeds your desired salary?
- Are you confident in your ability to handle real payroll, including the correct deductions and filings?
- What tax does your state charge S corporations directly, and does it offer a pass-through entity tax election? For example, California offered an elective 9.3% pass-through entity tax on qualified net income for the 2025 tax year, and has since extended the election through 2030 (California Franchise Tax Board, 2025).
- Is your bookkeeping system clean enough to track distributions and basis?
If you can't answer these questions with confidence, you should talk to a professional before filing anything.
Your next step
The S corporation isn't a magic solution. It's a trade-off: you take on payroll, a corporate tax return and state obligations in exchange for the potential to save on self-employment taxes. If done well, with reasonable compensation documented and basis tracked, it can genuinely help a profitable business to keep more of its earnings. If done carelessly, however, it can result in penalties and reclassified wages.
The smart move is to run your actual numbers past someone who is familiar with both federal and state rules. Get in touch with a Catholic accountant who understands your community. Submit your details through Heritage Web's secure referral form. A good S Corp CPA can advise you on whether the election is appropriate for your situation, before a deadline forces you to make a decision.
This article is general information, not tax advice. Tax rules change each year; speak with a CPA or enrolled agent about your situation.