Parish Neighbors: How S Corporation Taxes Work

S corporation taxes explained for Catholic small-business owners and families. Covers how pass-through income works, where self-employment tax savings come from, the reasonable-salary rule courts have enforced, Form 1120-S penalties, shareholder basis and the QBI deduction — plus how to decide if the election fits your business and find an accountant who understands your community.

Accounting Services Tax Services Startup Accounting
Parish Neighbors: How S Corporation Taxes Work

If you own a small business in your local community, such as a landscaping company, dental practice or family bakery, you may have been advised to "become an S corp" to save on taxes. However, most people who recommend this can't explain what it actually means. It is the difference between the pitch and the paperwork that causes business owners to get into trouble.

Here's some scale to start with. For tax year 2023, the IRS counted 5,440,879 active Form 1120-S returns, which reported $814.531 billion in pretax net income minus deficit (IRS, 2023). That's a lot of businesses relying on the same tax structure. Catholic business owners are part of this group, though no data isolates their share — the Pew Research Center estimated that there were approximately 53 million Catholic adults in the United States in 2024, spread across all regions, with 29% in the South and 26% in the Northeast (Pew Research Center, 2025).

An S corporation can offer genuine tax benefits. However, it also comes with payroll rules and a separate tax return, not to mention penalties that can mount up quickly if you miss a deadline. This article explains how the structure works, who it helps and where the pitfalls lie, so you can have an informed conversation with an accountant instead of passively accepting a sales pitch.

Key takeaways

  • An S corporation is a pass-through entity, meaning that profits are generally taxed on the owners' tax returns rather than at the company level.
  • For tax years 2024 and 2025, the self-employment tax rate was 15.3% — 12.4% for Social Security and 2.9% for Medicare (IRS, 2025).
  • Owners who work in the business are expected to pay themselves 'reasonable compensation' as a salary, and courts have reclassified distributions as wages when they didn't.
  • Late filing of Form 1120-S carried a penalty of $245 per shareholder per month for the 2024 tax year and $255 for the 2025 tax year (IRS, 2025).
  • As state rules vary widely, you should check with your own state's revenue department.